By Serina Deen, MDMPH
When I first see patients for evaluation, they often tell me
that they’ve debated starting a “biological” treatment such as medication,
versus a “psychological” treatment such as psychotherapy. I’m happy to report
that as brain imaging technology advances, we’re finding that this distinction
may be obsolete.
Psychotherapy is also “biological” in that it can lead to
real functional and structural changes in the brain. In fact, sometimes psychotherapy and
medication produce surprisingly similar changes in the brain. We still have a lot to learn about the topic,
but below are some examples of what researchers have been finding so far.
Functional Changes in
the Brain:
In one study, researchers at UCLA found that people who
suffered from depression had abnormally high activity in an area of the brain
called the prefrontal cortex. Those who
got better after they were treated with a type of therapy called interpersonal
therapy (IPT) showed a decrease in activity in the prefrontal cortex after
treatment. In other words, IPT seemed to
“normalize” brain activity in this hyperactive region.
Another study looked at people who have obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), who tend to have an overactive area of the brain called the
caudate nucleus. Treatment with a type
of therapy called cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) was associated with a
decrease in the hyperactivity of the caudate nucleus, and the effect was most
evident in people who had a good response to CBT. In other words, the better the therapy seemed
to work, the more the brain activity changed.
Changes in Brain
Volume:
People with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) suffer from debilitating
fatigue. People with CFS tend to have a
decrease in a type of brain tissue called grey matter in the prefrontal cortex
of the brain. Researchers in the
Netherlands gave people with CFS 16 sessions of CBT, and found significant
increases in gray matter volume in the prefrontal cortex. This seems to suggest that the CFS patients
were able to “recover” some gray matter volume after CBT.
Similarities and
Differences to Medications
Psychotherapy sometimes seems to work in similar ways as
medications, and other times appears to have different mechanisms of action.
In the study mentioned previously about people with
depression, both IPT and the antidepressant paroxetine (Paxil) showed a
decrease in prefrontal cortex activity. And
with OCD patients, both CBT and the antidepressant fluoxetine (Prozac) produced
similar decreases in activity in the caudate nucleus.
However in a different study, the antidepressant Venlafaxine
(Effexor) produced changes in different parts of the brain than IPT in
depressed patients. This shows that there
is variability in how different treatments work in the brain.
How Psychotherapy
Produces Brain Change
We now know that the brain keeps changing, even after we
become adults. Learning leads to the
production of new proteins, which in turn can change connectivity in our brains
in a process called neuroplasticity. Indeed, researchers in Germany showed that
certain neurochemicals involved in neuroplasticity increased in depressed
patients who got better after a course of interpersonal therapy.
Picking a Treatment
that Works Best for You
Even though we know that both medication and psychotherapy
can change our brain, we still have a long way to go in learning exactly how
that happens and when to use what treatment. Given a specific mental illness,
sometimes medications work best, sometimes psychotherapies are the best option,
and sometimes it’s a combination of the two.
In addition, there are different types of psychotherapies that work for
different illnesses, just as there are many different types of
medications. If you’re considering
seeking help for mental illness, it would be helpful to talk with a trained
professional about what would work best for you.
Read tips on what to expect during your first visit with a psychiatrist
"Let's Talk Facts" brochure on Psychotherapy
Brain Awareness blog post from NIMH Director Tom Insel, MD
APA Releases List
of Five Uses of Psychiatric Medication to Question
Six tips for talking to your doctor about medication
For more information about psychotherapy
When I first see patients for evaluation, they often tell me
that they’ve debated starting a “biological” treatment such as medication,
versus a “psychological” treatment such as psychotherapy. I’m happy to report
that as brain imaging technology advances, we’re finding that this distinction
may be obsolete.
Psychotherapy is also “biological” in that it can lead to
real functional and structural changes in the brain. In fact, sometimes psychotherapy and
medication produce surprisingly similar changes in the brain. We still have a lot to learn about the topic,
but below are some examples of what researchers have been finding so far.
Functional Changes in
the Brain:
In one study, researchers at UCLA found that people whosuffered from depression had abnormally high activity in an area of the brain
called the prefrontal cortex. Those who
got better after they were treated with a type of therapy called interpersonal
therapy (IPT) showed a decrease in activity in the prefrontal cortex after
treatment. In other words, IPT seemed to
“normalize” brain activity in this hyperactive region.
Another study looked at people who have obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), who tend to have an overactive area of the brain called the
caudate nucleus. Treatment with a type
of therapy called cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) was associated with a
decrease in the hyperactivity of the caudate nucleus, and the effect was most
evident in people who had a good response to CBT. In other words, the better the therapy seemed
to work, the more the brain activity changed.
Changes in Brain
Volume:
People with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) suffer from debilitating
fatigue. People with CFS tend to have a
decrease in a type of brain tissue called grey matter in the prefrontal cortex
of the brain. Researchers in the
Netherlands gave people with CFS 16 sessions of CBT, and found significant
increases in gray matter volume in the prefrontal cortex. This seems to suggest that the CFS patients
were able to “recover” some gray matter volume after CBT.
Similarities and
Differences to Medications
Psychotherapy sometimes seems to work in similar ways as
medications, and other times appears to have different mechanisms of action.
In the study mentioned previously about people with
depression, both IPT and the antidepressant paroxetine (Paxil) showed a
decrease in prefrontal cortex activity. And
with OCD patients, both CBT and the antidepressant fluoxetine (Prozac) produced
similar decreases in activity in the caudate nucleus.
However in a different study, the antidepressant Venlafaxine
(Effexor) produced changes in different parts of the brain than IPT in
depressed patients. This shows that there
is variability in how different treatments work in the brain.
How Psychotherapy
Produces Brain Change
We now know that the brain keeps changing, even after we
become adults. Learning leads to the
production of new proteins, which in turn can change connectivity in our brains
in a process called neuroplasticity. Indeed, researchers in Germany showed that
certain neurochemicals involved in neuroplasticity increased in depressed
patients who got better after a course of interpersonal therapy.
Picking a Treatment
that Works Best for You
Even though we know that both medication and psychotherapy
can change our brain, we still have a long way to go in learning exactly how
that happens and when to use what treatment. Given a specific mental illness,
sometimes medications work best, sometimes psychotherapies are the best option,
and sometimes it’s a combination of the two.
In addition, there are different types of psychotherapies that work for
different illnesses, just as there are many different types of
medications. If you’re considering
seeking help for mental illness, it would be helpful to talk with a trained
professional about what would work best for you.
Read tips on what to expect during your first visit with a psychiatrist
"Let's Talk Facts" brochure on Psychotherapy
Brain Awareness blog post from NIMH Director Tom Insel, MD
APA Releases List
of Five Uses of Psychiatric Medication to Question
Six tips for talking to your doctor about medication
For more information about psychotherapy
